Rotator Cuff Tears - Predictive Factors For Management

Rotator cuff tears are very common and it is wellwith rotator cuff tears who were managed
known that their prevalence increases with age. Onenon-operatively. Evaluations were performed via
common kinematic dysfunction seen in rotator cuffreview of magnetic resonance imaging studies and
deficient patients is proximal migration of the humeralresults were correlated with age and anatomical
head. This is particularly so since one major function ofvariables, among others.
the intact rotator cuff complex is to stabilize thePertinent results from this study include:
humeral head within the center of the glenoid fossa• Grouping follow-up time of non-operative
upon movement of the upper extremity.treatment on a continuous scale (from 25 months), the
Pain, tear location, and tear size all have beenodds ratio for an increase in rotator cuff tear size was
implicated in altered glenohumeral mechanics, however,2.1 as follow-up time doubled. Significantly more
their specific effects remain relatively unknown. Thesefull-thickness tears increased in size as compared to
particular factors may play an important role for us asthose partially torn.
diagnosticians and manual therapists, since a proper• When patients were classified either as
understanding of each may influence the treatmentyounger-than or older-than 60 years of age,
plans within our scopes of practice. Specifically, do thesignificantly more tears progressed in size in the older
presence or characteristics of any of the above (orgroup.
other) predictive factors have the potential to guide the• While only 8% of tears decreased in size over
management of rotator cuff disease and dictatetime, none of these were from shoulders whose tears
whether or not conservative care will be sufficient, orinvolved more than one tendon.
can specific characteristics predict whether surgical• No significant relationships were found among
management is warranted? These questions form theacromioclavicular joint arthritis, acromial spurs, and
basis of the studies included in this review.supraspinatus atrophy with tear progression. However,
Pertinent Results:tear size progression was significantly more common
To shed some light on the questions above, twoin those shoulders that demonstrated fatty infiltration of
separate studies were reviewed together.the musculature. (Note: the presence of fatty infiltration
Keener et al. specifically examined the relative effectswas no different in the partial- and full-thickness
that rotator cuff tear size and pain had on proximalgroups.)
humeral migration in both symptomatic andClinical Application & Conclusions:
asymptomatic individuals with rotator cuff deficientVarious factors influencing the kinematics of the
shoulders. The premise for the inclusion of subjectsglenohumeral joint were examined in the first study.
with and without pain was to provide insight as toThrough the simultaneous inclusion of both
whether or not pain modalities and/or medication havesymptomatic and asymptomatic individuals, as well as
the potential to influence glenohumeral kinematics in aa multivariate analysis of potential predictors, it was
clinical setting.revealed that proximal humeral migration was
Pertinent results from this study include:significantly related to rotator cuff tear size and the
• Average proximal humeral migration ininvolvement of the infraspinatus tendon.
symptomatic individuals was significantly greater than inFurther, long-term follow up of individuals who receive
those who did not suffer from pain (migration: 0.26 +conservative care for such injuries involving the rotator
1.6 mm vs -0.28 + 1.3 mm)cuff complex provides valuable insight not only to
• For both symptomatic and asymptomaticanatomical changes that may or may not result over
individuals, proximal humeral migration was significantlytime, but also to the cost-effectiveness of such
greater in those shoulders whose tears involved thenon-operative treatment. As such, it was
infraspinatus (either alone or in conjunction with thedemonstrated that progression of rotator cuff tears
supraspinatus). Interestingly, infraspinatus involvementwas more likely to occur in patients older than 60
was significantly more frequent in the symptomaticyears, those involving a full-thickness tear, and in
group.shoulders demonstrating fatty infiltration upon magnetic
• Symptomatic rotator cuff tears with an area >resonance imaging.
175mm-squared significantly correlated with alteredAs demonstrated from the findings within these two
glenohumeral mechanics (proximal migration)studies, one may deduce that conservative
• While pain significantly correlated with migrationmanagement alone may not be sufficient in those
and tear area in full-thickness tears > 175mm-squared,individuals presenting with the specific characteristics
this relationship was negated upon multivariate analysisdescribed above. Therefore, in conjunction with an initial
(where tear area was the most significant predictor ofattempt at rehabilitative care, prudent
proximal migration).patient-management would also include simultaneous
Maman et al. evaluated the outcomes of individualsreferral for orthopaedic consultation.